Author Topic: Board restrictions to new members  (Read 10849 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline truecam

  • Peasant
  • *
  • Posts: 92
  • Cookies: -46
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #75 on: January 17, 2016, 08:04:57 am »
No drastic action needs to be taken.

Poor or random posts are dealt with or not counted.

The karma system is good.

The test is suitable for all skill levels.
Not really. There is a large amount of new intros. There is a lot of dead user accounts. There is a lot of shit posts. Not drastic measure. Just measures against the watering down of the community. It does not make sense for a website to say they value quality over quantity if we have a good deal of lechers and shit posters more so than actual good content. I refuse to accept your standards greycat.
« Last Edit: January 18, 2016, 03:16:29 am by truecam »

Offline Kulverstukas

  • Administrator
  • Zeus
  • *
  • Posts: 6627
  • Cookies: 542
  • Fascist dictator
    • View Profile
    • My blog
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #76 on: January 17, 2016, 08:05:46 am »
I agree with GreyCat... we're not leaving shitposts to float, we are still moderating the forum and shitposts didn't increase since the time we did this.
« Last Edit: January 17, 2016, 08:06:34 am by Kulverstukas »

Offline dimi

  • Serf
  • *
  • Posts: 37
  • Cookies: 2
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #77 on: January 17, 2016, 02:30:34 pm »
I think the quality is pretty good. It s a no nonsese moderating system. I mean. If you ask something you can google, this will be said. The more 'difficult' things are discussed. For me, this is the only forum I like to follow. It may be bullshit or bad quality for you, but I already learned a lot with just reading the topics.

Offline truecam

  • Peasant
  • *
  • Posts: 92
  • Cookies: -46
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #78 on: January 17, 2016, 06:46:52 pm »
I think the quality is pretty good. It s a no nonsese moderating system. I mean. If you ask something you can google, this will be said. The more 'difficult' things are discussed. For me, this is the only forum I like to follow. It may be bullshit or bad quality for you, but I already learned a lot with just reading the topics.
I enjoy this forum to, but I just do not see the quality getting any better.

Offline iTpHo3NiX

  • EZ's Pirate Captain
  • Administrator
  • Titan
  • *
  • Posts: 2920
  • Cookies: 328
    • View Profile
    • EvilZone
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #79 on: January 17, 2016, 11:34:39 pm »
I enjoy this forum to, but I just do not see the quality getting any better.

And where's your quality? Hrm I can't seem to find any...
[09:27] (+lenoch) iTpHo3NiX can even manipulate me to suck dick
[09:27] (+lenoch) oh no that's voluntary
[09:27] (+lenoch) sorry

Offline truecam

  • Peasant
  • *
  • Posts: 92
  • Cookies: -46
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #80 on: January 18, 2016, 12:17:59 am »
And where's your quality? Hrm I can't seem to find any...

I see your point, but it does not disprove mine at all. Maybe I am not the right messenger, because I have 0 reputation here, but I just had to get something off my chest. Regardless of my faggotry, my point still stands.
« Last Edit: January 18, 2016, 12:22:53 am by truecam »

Offline Insanity

  • EZ's Jailbait
  • Peasant
  • *
  • Posts: 51
  • Cookies: 51
  • I'm at your window right now...doing.....something
    • View Profile
    • YO PROFILE
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #81 on: January 18, 2016, 07:10:06 am »
//Here is my two cents on the issue:

    truecam is right. Even is he isn't the biggest info contributer, he still is someone who frequents the forum, and has been doing so for a while. He opinion is no less valid than mine, or anyone else's. (Well, anyone being people who don't just solely come here to leech and fucking shitpost. Those who at least spend some time on the forum or IRC and genuinely cares about Evilzone. truecam obviously cares about Evilzone, which is why he's pointing it out.)

    Evilzone is pretty much filled with worthless or outdated posts, although there are some posts that really shine through, those are few and far between. Of course, being less a contributer and more a leecher myself means I have no room to talk, but at least I try not to litter the forum with worthless threads and shitposts. I think Evilzone does indeed need more quality-control.
    If you don't know, I'm not as active on the forum (mainly because everything in my unreads are not interesting or I have nothing to say on them) but I spend my every living second (kind of an exaggeration, but pretty close to home) of my life on the IRC. I've seen the idiots who come in the #register channel and attempt to find the code, with no ability to read or observe something new for them. Personally, when I registered on EZ, the topic of #register did not say anything about the !help command. Even now that it does, I still see the occasional (not even occasional, by now it's a pretty prominent thing) half-brained fool that jumps in the channel and immediately starts either spamming someone with PMs or just asks straight up in the channel "how get register code"...with the grammatical prowess of a 5 year old.
    One example of what happened earlier today:
Quote
<creed> !help
<register-bot> You are probably looking for the !code command ;)
<creed> lol
<puddi> come on
<puddi> you're close
<creed> this is harder than i imagined
<puddi> yup
<puddi> plenty of newbies struggle
<creed> oo ok
<puddi> so what do we do now
<creed> just tryen to figure it out
    This isn't an isolated incident, either...this happens all the fucking time. The sad story is that eventually the idiot does manage to get the code. Every time. This isn't quality control, it's just sending an idiot into the IRC (which, if they happen to speak in the main channel, I will end up greeting...and they never leave...). I need to be meaner, apparently.
Quote

<anton> !help
<register-bot> You are probably looking for the !code command ;)
<anton> !code
<anton> !code smth
<anton> !help
<register-bot> You are probably looking for the !code command ;)
<anton> !help code
<register-bot> You are probably looking for the !code command ;)
<anton> !code help
    Sometimes it's not even THAT!! Holy fucking shit, just now:
Quote
<brant> * Youngboss (~rough_coi@3BF13127.3C97B6C.702FCAB3.IP) has joined
<Insanity> brant, don't be a fag
<brant> +w
<brant>  /MOTD
<Insanity> Yup, I see, you're gonna be a fag. Damnit.
    The stupidity makes me want to literally die. Not figuratively, literally. What happens to these idiots? Yeah, they get heckled, sure, but what matters is that they still make it into a position where they could become a gigantic nuisance. Once it was so bad to the point where Xires actually set the topic to: So you want to register eh? | Try !help | If you ask others for the code you will be banned!! | THIS IS A TEST TO DETERMINE YOUR ABILITY TO EDUCATE YOURSELF ON THE SIMPLEST OF TASKS! IF YOU CANNOT PASS FOR YOURSELF, YOU DON'T BELONG HERE!
I remember that day. Once the idiot who enraged Xires figured out how to get the code, that same idiot decided to help his many other idiot-lings on getting the code....which should be in clear violation of the rules...
    "If you ask others for the code you will be banned!!". I do not see that rule being enforced. I think in the whole time I've been on the IRC, I've seen one banned (in #register), and it wasn't even for asking people for the code. I think it was also at the same time MrJ was feeding his idiot-lings the code, but it's been a while and I can't remember well. Idiots usually come into #register, ask for the code, and having no repercussions they continue onwards with their idiotic tendencies. All I know is that Evilzone is not exactly doing well in what they purport.... "Quality/Quantity" is not something that has been accomplished in Evilzone. It's not impossible, either, there could definitely be some sort of quality-control. They could hash the code, give a little registration test, just...anything......please........
    Plus, I'm not the only one who thinks this, clearly evident by not only truecam but the many others who I've seen talk about thier disgust for Evilzone's lack of an ability to weed out those with an IQ under 70.

I think the quality is pretty good. It s a no nonsese moderating system. I mean. If you ask something you can google, this will be said. The more 'difficult' things are discussed. For me, this is the only forum I like to follow. It may be bullshit or bad quality for you, but I already learned a lot with just reading the topics.
HAHAHAHAHAHAAAA!!!! Hmmrmm, sorry about that, but...just...what the fuck is wrong with you?
Do you not know what quality means?
"It s a no nonsese moderating system"....uhuh...yeah...
https://evilzone.org/c-c/looking-to-learn-c/?topicseen
^ Retarded thread. Obvious reasons.
https://evilzone.org/hacking-and-security/password-security/?topicseen
^ Retarded thread. Obvious reasons.
https://evilzone.org/found-it-on-the-webs/security-conference-videos/?topicseen
^ Retarded thread. (For anyone who already has done their research....which is not many....)
https://evilzone.org/hacking-newbies/ping-of-death-works-or-not/?topicseen
^ Retarded thread. Person doesn't even know what he's talking about. (This one is a little harsh, I'll admit it.)

I could go on...and these are only threads in my unreads. (I check my unreads pretty much daily) The problem here is that a lot of the volume of EZ are these threads and posts. If you take them away, EZ will pretty much be left with a very minuscule amount of content.
If you think that the threads you see on EZ is difficult, then by all means continue to learn and grow here. Just don't hold the whole fucking forum back because you can't understand the difference between good quality and bad quality posts/threads.

No drastic action needs to be taken.

Poor or random posts are dealt with or not counted.

The karma system is good.

The test is suitable for all skill levels.
I think unless your head has been in the sand since you joined, you should know that drastic actions are being taken. We're "moving" to IPS.......
(I put that in quotes because the due date has passed, and I'm not sure whether EZ is going to just give up on the whole project. That would be dispicable, seeing how much time and effort people like iTpHo3NiX and DarkVision spent on going through the mirror, and how Xires and Kulverstukas have spent so much money on it....which are only a couple things that would have gone to waste)
"Poor or random posts are dealt with or not counted." that isn't true at all. Take a look at your own post count, for instance. And, in case you need more prodding to understand, check out my reply to dimi.
    I agree that the karma system is fine, that was never a problem nor was it presented as such. The karma system is not meant to signify someone who is smart or anything, it's just meant to signify how much people like you. You can be a genius with great posts, but hated with a low cookie count. Or, you could be the most retarded person to walk the Earth with a high cookie count. Cookies are not meant to be taken into consideration when you think about the validity of someone's posts or the such. Not sure why you brought them up, they did nothing to further your point or anyone else's.
"The test is suitable for all skill levels."
    The problem is that....THERE IS NO FUCKING TEST!!! Holy fucking shit, and what skill level are we trying to reach?! The ability to type: "!help" then read, then type: "!code" again?!? Holy fuck nut, you must be the most retarded person to walk planet Earth if you think that, THAT system is enough to keep out people who are completely worthless. It's ridiculous. You don't understand. You don't hang around all day watching all these stupid people getting the code, knowing in your heart that later that day there will be 5+ retarded shitposts or threads in your unreads....for each person....people who spam the damned boards on philosophical threads or on threads that are made up solely of what your favourite song or whatever is....just to hit the 20 post count. I find it very aggravating, and so meh.

/* I'm out of anger now, so yeah, I'll go back to my corner of brewing hatred. This all may seem like me being an asshole or just bitching, but if Evilzone continues being a cesspool of nonsense then eventually people will get tired of it's bullshit. :/ */
« Last Edit: January 18, 2016, 08:18:54 am by Insanity »
"Potatoes can fly" - Ande
<V> OK. Insanity is so fine she should be on the cover of Vanity no pun intended but she takes away my Sanity. This rhymes a bit lame but no prob Caz I aint got no shame. Last thing I gotta say is insanity is that your beautiful like a dove and I hope you accept love
* Silver_Solstice has quit (Quit: Friends help you move. Real friends help you move bodies.)

Offline overflow

  • Serf
  • *
  • Posts: 21
  • Cookies: 5
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #82 on: January 18, 2016, 01:35:45 pm »
Not that I have anything to say as I'm pretty new around but the issue of inactivity might lie at IRC. I see a lot of activity on IRC as opposed to the forum. Maybe we should do a chatbox in here and see how that goes.
"Personally, I make it a habit to avoid habits."

Offline iTpHo3NiX

  • EZ's Pirate Captain
  • Administrator
  • Titan
  • *
  • Posts: 2920
  • Cookies: 328
    • View Profile
    • EvilZone
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #83 on: January 18, 2016, 05:01:49 pm »
Not that I have anything to say as I'm pretty new around but the issue of inactivity might lie at IRC. I see a lot of activity on IRC as opposed to the forum. Maybe we should do a chatbox in here and see how that goes.

No
[09:27] (+lenoch) iTpHo3NiX can even manipulate me to suck dick
[09:27] (+lenoch) oh no that's voluntary
[09:27] (+lenoch) sorry

Offline b00ms1ang

  • Peasant
  • *
  • Posts: 65
  • Cookies: -8
  • Oh
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #84 on: January 18, 2016, 08:11:40 pm »
And where's your quality? Hrm I can't seem to find any...

OOOOHOHOOOOO

Anyway, as someone who leaves this forum on almost all day and reads every single post, but just doesnt post much, I see absolutely no problem with the way EvilZone runs. The activity level and quality is actually really nice compared to other security forums I have been a part of. Bullcrap is dealt with quickly, the IRC remains as an active social unit, and good tutorials and posts stay where they should be. All in all, 7.5/10 for forum crunchies (needs more titties). And if users have to earn their salt by participating? I think that's great. It really doesn't take that long to ask some questions, respond to feedback, and try out some of the readily available tutorials.
Oh...

Offline xKiller

  • NULL
  • Posts: 3
  • Cookies: -1
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #85 on: February 02, 2016, 07:56:51 pm »
You're right! A lot of members have acces to a lot of stuff
"If I give you my brain , your body is going crazy "  Andrei Versace - greatest physicist and mathematician of all time, also and a genius in physchology

Offline zombie

  • /dev/null
  • *
  • Posts: 19
  • Cookies: 3
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #86 on: February 03, 2016, 08:58:36 am »
I think this system of making people have 20 posts to get access to special boards is a poor way to manage the community. Yes, I understand that the logic behind it was that only contributing members of the community would be able to make it to such a post count and get access to the boards, but I think there is a flaw in this logic.

Let's say you are a new member and you don't really care about EvilZone(leech). How will you reach those 20 posts to get access to the ebooks board? You will make low quality posts. Now, they may not be low quality enough to warrant deletion, but in 9/10 cases it will be some stupid shitty non-contribution to the discussion that is just barely good enough to not get deleted--probably just a hair above the incredibly low standards that already exist. Rinse, repeat, do that 20 times on whatever thread you can manage to slip a post in, and voila! You have your 20 posts and now have access to the ebooks.

This mindset clearly needs to be eradicated, and there are two trivial ways to fix this method. One way is to make the process of joining the forum more rigorous. Doesn't have to be some intense Cicada 3301 shit, but just something more, maybe something like Insanity mentioned, where you hash the registration code or have a two-step registration process. Another way to fix it is to increase the strictness of the moderation. By raising the bar it would hence make it harder for floaters to come in and do the bare minimum. I think the heavier moderation idea sounds shitty as it requires more effort and more forum nazism, which ruins the fun for everyone, but I also think that the former option isn't powerful enough on it's own.

By having a mixture, where there is a more rigorous application process and a stronger community initiative to make sure that only competent individuals complete registration and that the forums aren't filled with shit posts whose only purpose serves to increase post count, the quality of EvilZone would improve as a whole. I don't see it as requiring much effort; simply have a step-up of difficulty in registration and implement a simple method to eradicate nonsense on the forums and in IRC--like actually banning people that break rules that threaten to ban people that break them(like helping other users register).

So yeah. I am writing this late at night so this is probably shit and I will probably regret this as i recognize that I am not some ultra notorious member of EvilZone, but who cares, take from it what you will. Too many people are complaining that there is an issue, but I don't see a ton of solutions being offered, so here's one at least.

Good luck fuckers.
« Last Edit: February 03, 2016, 09:00:23 am by zombie »

Offline iTpHo3NiX

  • EZ's Pirate Captain
  • Administrator
  • Titan
  • *
  • Posts: 2920
  • Cookies: 328
    • View Profile
    • EvilZone
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #87 on: February 03, 2016, 05:42:10 pm »
Honestly given my way I would simply make the eBooks board invite only. I would also not allow half the shit that gets posted here but whenever I delete some bullshit I get met with bullshit so I'm like fuck this bullshit
[09:27] (+lenoch) iTpHo3NiX can even manipulate me to suck dick
[09:27] (+lenoch) oh no that's voluntary
[09:27] (+lenoch) sorry

Offline dimi

  • Serf
  • *
  • Posts: 37
  • Cookies: 2
    • View Profile
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #88 on: February 03, 2016, 09:09:26 pm »
I didnt join the forum for the ebooks. They are nice but eventually you will find a particular ebook in the internet when you want it. I joined it because i want to learn things. Because i know nothing i dont contribute much. But what i do is appreciate all your efforts for this site. I know it costs you guys money and it is your project besides your everyday stuff. Anyhow. If things change, i would definitely do my best to get in the evilzone again. I'm often astonished by the intelligence of some (very few) of the guys and girls who put their energy in this site. I think you dont realize how smart you are. This said, the beginners questions may seem very easy for you. The problem is the smart ones play in the first league and the beginners in amateur league. Everyone had to learn once.

I think that a small test to get in may shift the leechers, so zombie is right. But it also may not.. But when you never try, you will never know. I think you guys are smart enough to find a solution.

Offline iTpHo3NiX

  • EZ's Pirate Captain
  • Administrator
  • Titan
  • *
  • Posts: 2920
  • Cookies: 328
    • View Profile
    • EvilZone
Re: Board restrictions to new members
« Reply #89 on: February 03, 2016, 10:41:10 pm »
We have a solution and have had a solution, it's just not implemented. In any case this thread is for information, not a debate or an idea board. If you have ideas post them in the feedback board.

Also most of you are failing to realize that leechers are not the only reason the eBooks have been hidden. This choice was also decided because of DCMA. It protects the staff, as well as the host. If auto crawlers from copyright trolls can't find the content, then it can't be reported. Hosts will only put up with so much crap before terminating your services with them.

Now I'm sick of this thread showing up in my unread posts for no reason

</thread>
[09:27] (+lenoch) iTpHo3NiX can even manipulate me to suck dick
[09:27] (+lenoch) oh no that's voluntary
[09:27] (+lenoch) sorry